Study Report 13

The 4th of the FOUR Methods:
Chapter on Wheel based on Pure Aggregates (Suddha khandha mūlacakkavāro)

Positive (Anulomaṃ)

[16/211]
Pali Text:
(i) Rūpaṃ khandho? Khandhā vedanā?
(ii) Rūpaṃ khandho? Khandhā saññā?
(iii) Rūpaṃ khandho? Khandhā saṅkhārā?
(iv) Rūpaṃ khandho? Khandhā viññāṇaṃ?

Translation:
(i) It is rūpa. Is it aggregate? They are aggregates. Are they feeling?
(ii) It is rūpa. Is it aggregate? They are aggregates. Are they perception?
(iii) It is rūpa. Is it aggregate? They are aggregates. Are they formations?
(iv) It is rūpa. Is it aggregate? They are aggregates. Are they consciousness?

[17/211]
Pali Text:
(i) Vedanā khandho? Khandhā rūpaṃ?
(ii) Vedanā khandho? Khandhā saññā?
(iii) Vedanā khandho? Khandhā saṅkhārā?
(iv) Vedanā khandho? Khandhā viññāṇaṃ?

Translation:
(i) It is feeling. Is it aggregate? They are aggregates. Are they rūpa?
(ii) It is feeling. Is it aggregate? They are aggregates. Are they perception?
(iii) It is feeling. Is it aggregate? They are aggregates. Are they formations?
(iv) It is feeling. Is it aggregate? They are aggregates. Are they consciousness?

[18/211]
Pali Text:
(i) Saññā khandho? Khandhā rūpaṃ?
(ii) Saññā khandho? Khandhā vedanā?
(iii) Saññā khandho? Khandhā saṅkhārā?
(iv) Saññā khandho? Khandhā viññāṇaṃ?

Translation:
(i) It is perception. Is it aggregate? They are aggregates. Are they rūpa?
(ii) It is perception. Is it aggregate? They are aggregates. Are they feeling?
(iii) It is perception. Is it aggregate? They are aggregates. Are they formations?
(iv) It is perception. Is it aggregate? They are aggregates. Are they consciousness?

[19/211]
Pali Text:
(i) Saṅkhārā khandho? Khandhā rūpaṃ?
(ii) Saṅkhārā khandho? Khandhā vedanā?
(iii) Saṅkhārā khandho? Khandhā saññā?
(iv) Saṅkhārā khandho? Khandhā viññāṇaṃ?

Translation:
(i) They are formations. Are they aggregates? They are aggregates. Are they rūpa?
(ii) They are formations. Are they aggregates? They are aggregates. Are they feeling?
(iii) They are formations. Are they aggregates? They are aggregates. Are they perception?
(iv) They are formations. Are they aggregates? They are aggregates. Are they consciousness?

[20/211]
Pali Text:
(i) Viññāṇaṃ khandho? Khandhā rūpaṃ?
(ii) Viññāṇaṃ khandho? Khandhā vedanā?
(iii) Viññāṇaṃ khandho? Khandhā saññā?
(iv) Viññāṇaṃ khandho? Khandhā saṅkhārā?

Translation:
(i) It is consciousness. Is it aggregate? They are aggregates. Are they rūpa?
(ii) It is consciousness. Is it aggregate? They are aggregates. Are they feeling?
(iii) It is consciousness. Is it aggregate? They are aggregates. Are they perception?
(iv) It is consciousness. Is it aggregate? They are aggregates. Are they formations?